I Never Doubted the Church, I Doubted Myself

I don’t remember when I first read The Five Levels of Attachment by Don Miguel Ruiz Jr. According to my Amazon order history, I purchased it in June 2017, along with The Fifth Agreement. I had read The Four Agreements the month before and was interested in exploring more of the teachings.

I know that The Fifth Agreement sat on my shelf for about a year before I read it, but I can’t recall when I picked up The Five Levels of Attachment. What I do remember is how I applied its teachings to my religious beliefs, which makes me think I may not have read it until after I began questioning the religion I had followed my entire life.

Whenever I read it, the five levels became a guide for me as I navigated the process of letting go of my former beliefs.

My Experience with Attachment

I was raised in the Mormon church. Both of my parents were active members, and I grew up accepting the church’s claims that it was the one true church of Jesus Christ. I never questioned those claims. Instead, I questioned myself.

Everything in my life revolved around the church. My understanding of the world, my purpose in life, my relationships, and my expectations for eternity were all shaped by its teachings.

That didn’t mean I excluded people who believed differently. I had friends and relationships outside the church, and even as a missionary I approached people with an invitation rather than a demand. I believed wholeheartedly that they needed to accept the gospel to receive eternal salvation, but I didn’t reject them when they declined my invitation. Nor did I take their rejection personally.

My deeply held beliefs were a double-edged sword. On one hand, I spent my life striving to follow the example of Jesus, treating others with kindness and compassion. On the other hand, I privately judged myself for every shortcoming.

I didn’t doubt the church. I doubted my ability to live up to its expectations.

Looking back, I can see that my departure from the church wasn’t a sudden change. Something had been shifting for quite some time, even if I wasn’t consciously aware of it.

In November 2018, I encountered some claims about the church’s history that contradicted what I had been taught. I sought clarification from the church itself and was surprised to discover that it acknowledged the historical events, although it presented them with a different interpretation.

That was a breaking point for me.

Why hadn’t I been taught these things? Why had I been given a different understanding of the history? I concluded that either the church didn’t want me to know, or it didn’t think I could handle knowing. Neither possibility was appealing.

I began studying more, and as I did, something interesting happened.

The less attached I became to my beliefs, the more willing I was to consider other perspectives. And the more perspectives I considered, the less attached I became.

Ideas I had previously dismissed outright became ideas I was willing to explore. Voices I had been taught not to listen to suddenly had something to say that I was willing to hear.

It wasn’t an easy process. There was confusion, disappointment, and a great deal of anger. But there was also an unexpected sense of relief.

About two months after I first began expressing my doubts to my wife, my parents, and my church leaders, I was standing in my office when I made a decision.

Throughout my life, I had repeated a familiar declaration of faith: “I know the church is true.”

But standing there that day, I allowed myself to say something different.

“I no longer believe the church is true.”

I remember the relief I felt in that moment. I felt free.

I hadn’t resolved every question or figured out what I would believe instead. I had simply allowed myself to release a belief that had defined so much of my life.

The experience was surprisingly liberating.

Understanding the Five Levels

Don Miguel Ruiz Jr. didn’t write a guidebook for leaving the Mormon church. He wrote a book about our relationship with beliefs, ideas, and identities.

In The Five Levels of Attachment, he describes how we can hold beliefs at varying depths of attachment, from appreciating an idea without identifying with it to allowing that idea to become so deeply intertwined with our identity that we struggle to distinguish ourselves from it.

The five levels are:

  1. The Authentic Self — Experiencing life without defining ourselves by our attachments.
  2. Preference — Having preferences while remaining free to enjoy experiences that differ from them.
  3. Identity — Beginning to define ourselves through our preferences and beliefs.
  4. Internalization — Allowing those beliefs to influence our sense of worth and how we judge ourselves.
  5. Fanaticism — Becoming so attached to our beliefs that we attempt to impose them on reality and others.

The deeper our attachment, the more our experience becomes dependent on the world conforming to our expectations.

Reading about these levels gave me a way to recognize what was happening in my own life. I could see how my religious beliefs had become part of my identity and how my sense of worth had become dependent on my ability to live according to them.

I could also see that releasing those attachments didn’t require me to reject everything I had previously believed, although it would take several more years before I fully understood this.

I could continue to value the teachings of Jesus without accepting every claim made by the institution that had introduced me to them. I could appreciate the experiences I had within the church without insisting that its interpretation of those experiences was the only possible truth.

I didn’t have to replace one rigid belief system with another.

I could simply allow myself to explore.

Putting the Ideas into Practice

One of the most valuable lessons I took from this book is that there is nothing inherently wrong with having beliefs or preferences.

We all develop understandings of the world based on our experiences. We have opinions about what is good, what is right, and how things ought to be. These understandings help us navigate life.

The difficulty arises when we become so attached to those beliefs that we cannot comfortably experience anything that challenges them.

When a belief becomes part of our identity, disagreement can feel like a personal attack. When our sense of worth depends on that belief, uncertainty can become threatening. We may find ourselves defending ideas not because they are useful or accurate, but because we are afraid of what it would mean to let them go.

The practical application of The Five Levels of Attachment is to become aware of how we hold our beliefs.

Can I prefer something without demanding it?

Can I believe something without needing everyone else to agree?

Can I consider an opposing perspective without feeling threatened?

Can I discover that I was mistaken without deciding that I am somehow less valuable because of it?

These questions aren’t limited to religion. They apply to politics, relationships, careers, personal identities, and even our expectations for how an ordinary day should unfold.

Holding a belief lightly doesn’t mean abandoning it. It means allowing the belief to remain open to experience.

I can believe something is true based on everything I currently understand, while remaining willing to discover something new.

I don’t need to prove my beliefs to everyone else, and I don’t need to defend them as though my existence depends on their validity.

If a belief continues to serve me, I can keep it. If new experiences challenge it, I can reconsider it.

And if I discover that it no longer reflects my understanding of reality, I can let it go.

Moving On

The Five Levels of Attachment helped me recognize that much of my suffering wasn’t necessarily coming from what I believed, but from how tightly I held those beliefs.

My experience leaving the church was painful, but the process also showed me that I could release beliefs I once considered inseparable from who I was.

I didn’t disappear when my beliefs changed. I was still here.

In fact, I found myself more comfortable with uncertainty, more open to different perspectives, and less burdened by the need to make reality conform to my expectations.

I think that’s where this book can be especially helpful. Whether you’re questioning a lifelong belief system or simply noticing how frustrated you become when things don’t go your way, understanding attachment can help you recognize the expectations influencing your experience.

We don’t have to stop believing, stop preferring, or stop pursuing the things that matter to us.

We can simply loosen our grip.

And perhaps, in doing so, discover that we never needed to hold on quite so tightly in the first place.

Comments

One response to “I Never Doubted the Church, I Doubted Myself”

  1. The Five Levels of Attachment — Don Miguel Ruiz Jr. – Imagine Moving On Avatar

    […] If you’re interested in how I applied these teachings while navigating my departure from the Mormon church, I’ve shared more of that experience in this article. […]

    Like

Leave a Reply